Public Servants Are Pushing Back Against AI—Teachers and Nurses Consider Industrial Action 

Seeking efficiency gains, governments worldwide are pushing for greater adoption of AI in the public sector.

Facing the threat of losing work to automation, public sector workers, including teachers and nurses, are starting to fight back.

AI in the Public Sector

For governments, AI tools offer the chance to improve public services, streamline administrative processes and reduce costs.

Among the most commonly cited areas for improvement are digital portals and interfaces, where AI can enhance interactions with tax authorities, healthcare systems and other public services.

Internal systems for sharing and organizing data are also targets for AI-powered reform.

However, throughout the past year, some officials have expressed frustration with the slow uptake of the technology.

In one report last year, the European Commission blamed “complex public procurement processes, difficulties in data management, a lack of regulatory clarity, and concerns about bias in AI decision-making.”

Efficiency in Government Services

Governments’ increasingly aggressive push for AI adoption reflects the contemporary fashion for bureaucratic efficiency.

This trend has its most visible incarnation in Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).

However, the tendency toward lean government isn’t limited to the U.S. In the U.K., Kier Starmer’s center-left government has also embraced a focus on efficiency.

Starmer’s approach to government efficiency shares the same affinity for technological fixes as the DOGE, with Downing Street acknowledging that its AI strategy may lead to civil service job cuts.

On both sides of the Atlantic, AI edicts are having a ripple effect across public services. As workers increasingly fear the consequences, they have started to organize against unbridled adoption.

Unions Resist AI-Driven Cuts

Industrial action aimed at protecting jobs from AI is nothing new. Early battles include the 2023 Hollywood strike, which resulted in important protections for actors to prevent them from being unfairly replaced.

However, the threat to public sector workers represents a new frontier, and the possibility of industrial action is in the air.

In January, members of National Nurses United (NNU) marched to demand guaranteed staffing levels amid the rising adoption of AI healthcare tools.

Meanwhile, in the U.K., National Education Union General Secretary Daniel Kebede recently raised the alarm about the use of AI teaching assistants in the classroom.

“AI can be used in a progressive way or it can be used in the way of Elon Musk,” Kebede cautioned, warning that “his direction of travel is no teachers, no teaching assistants.”

Source: https://www.ccn.com/